Court of Appeal upturns Saraki acquittal by CCT orders retrial on three counts 

By / 2 years ago / Breaking, News, Society / No Comments
Court of Appeal upturns Saraki  acquittal by CCT orders retrial on three counts 

 

 

 

The Court of Appeal in Abuja has reversed Senate President Bukola Saraki’s acquittal of false assets declaration charges.

The appellate court, in a unanimous judgment by a three-man panel, led by Justice Tinuade Akomolafe Wilson, ordered Saraki to return to the Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT) for the continuation of his trial.

The court held that the prosecution led direct and credible evidence to establish a prima facie case against Saraki in three of the 18 counts contained in the charge for which he was tried.

The counts on which Saraki is to enter defence are 4, 5 and 6 in relation to his alleged failure to declare some houses he acquired in Ikoyi, Lagos.

In Count 4, Saraki is alleged to have falsified his Assets Declaration at the end of his tenure as Kwara State Governor in 2011 and on assumption of office as a senator in 2011 when he declared that he acquired No. 17A, McDonald, Ikoyi, Lagos.

The prosecution contended that the defendant falsely declared that he had acquired No 17A, McDonald, Ikoyi on 6th September 2006 from the proceeds of sale of rice and sugar.

In Count 5, he is also alleged to have falsified his Assets Declaration at the end of his tenure as Governor of Kwara State in 2011 and on assumption of office as a senator in 2011 when he declared that he acquired No. 17B, McDonald, Ikoyi Lagos.

The prosecution contended that the defendant falsely declared to have acquired No. 17A, McDonald, Ikoyi on 6th September 2006 from proceeds of sale of rice and sugar.

In Count 6, Saraki is accused of making a false declaration in the Assets Declaration Form at the end of tenure as governor in 2007 and on assumption of office as executive governor in 2007 when he failed to declare his outstanding loan liabilities of N315,054,355.92 out of the loan of N380,000,000 obtained from Guaranty Trust Bank Plc.

The CCT  on June 14, upheld Saraki’s no-case submission, discharged and acquitted him, a decision the Federal Government appealed.

The Appeal Court, in its judgment yesterday, resolved four out of the five issues identified for determination in favour of the appellant.

The court said the tribunal was wrong to have held that Saraki was not invited to make a statement in the course of investigating the allegations against him.

It said the Senate President made a statement in the course of investigation, which was tendered and admitted by the tribunal as Exhibit 46.

The appellate court also faulted the CCT’s decision that the joint investigation team constituted by the Code of Conduct Bureau (CCB) and the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to investigate the allegations against Saraki was unknown to law.

It said there was no law forbidding the CCB from collaborating with other investigating agencies of government to effectively discharge its mandate.

The court also faulted the tribunal for holding that the prosecution failed to prove its case by not tendering the original copies of Saraki’s assets declaration forms and his statement.

It said the certified true copies (CTC) of the forms and statement were sufficient under the law to be admitted as exhibits in favour of the prosecution.

On whether the tribunal was right to have upheld Saraki’s no-case submission, the appellate court resolved the issue against Saraki.

After a thorough analysis of the evidence led by the prosecution, the appellate court said the prosecution led credible and direct evidence in respect of three counts – 4, 5 and 6 – of the 18-count amended charge, to warrant his being called upon to enter his defence.

The court said the prosecution was unable to discharge the burden of proof placed on him by the law in relation to counts 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18.

It said some of the prosecution’s witnesses gave both oral and documentary hearsay evidence that were inadmissible in law. It also said the prosecution failed to call witnesses in relation to the 15 counts.

For instance, the court noted that the prosecution, though accused Saraki of earning double salaries from the Kwara State Government and as a senator, it failed to call witnesses from the Kwara State Government and the National Assembly in support of the allegation.

The court ordered that the case be remitted back to CCT for Saraki to enter his defence.

Other members of the panel – Justices Tenimu Y. Hassan and M. Mustapha – agreed with the lead judgment by Justice Akomlafe-Wilson.

A two-man panel of the CCT, headed by Danladi Umar, on June 14, 2017, upheld the no-case submission filed by Saraki after the prosecution, led by Rotimi Jacobs (SAN), closed its case after calling four witnesses and tendering 48 documentary exhibits.

In upholding the no-case submission, the tribunal dismissed the amended 18 counts preferred against Saraki on the grounds that the prosecution was unable to establish any prima facie case against the Senate President.

Umar, in his lead ruling, exonerated Saraki, holding that failure of the prosecution to obtain his statement and make it part of the proof of evidence was fatal to the case.

He adjudged as “absurd” that neither Saraki’s statement nor the report of the investigation said to have been carried out was produced before the tribunal.

He agreed with the defence team, led by Chief Kanu Agabi (SAN),  that the prosecution’s evidence had been manifestly discredited during cross-examination by the defence.

He added that the evidence adduced by the prosecution, led by Mr. Rotimi Jacobs (SAN), was “so unreliable that no reasonable tribunal could convict” based on it.

The tribunal chairman specifically noted that the third prosecution witness, Mr. Samuel Madojemu, who is Head, Intelligence Unit of the Code of Conduct Bureau, only gave hearsay evidence on the information the witness purportedly received from the EFCC.

But the Office of the Attorney-General of the Federation, through Jacobs, on June 20, filed a 17-ground notice of appeal against the CCT’s judgment.

The Federal Government faulted all the grounds on which the CCT predicated Saraki’s acquittal, describing the entire judgment as unreasonable and unconstitutional.

Jacobs subsequently filed an appellant’s brief on July 28, formulating five issues for determination.

Saraki, through his lead counsel Agabi, also filed his respondent’s brief on August 22.

While adopting his appellant’s brief on November 22, Jacobs urged the court to grant the Federal Government’s appeal and hold that the judgment of the CCT was perverse. He also reiterated that the CCT erred by adjudging the oral evidence of the prosecution’s third witness, Madojemu, the Head, Intelligence Unit of the CCB, as hearsay.

 

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

  Subscribe  
Notify of
trackback

銉椼兗銉?puma 銇畃uma by fenty rihanna 銉儱銉冦偗 銉愩儍銈儜銉冦偗

brooks 鏂板搧閫佹枡杈?銉栥儷銉冦偗銈?brooks 銉┿兂銉嬨兂銈般偡銉ャ兗銈?銈︺偅銉°兂銈?銉曘儹銉?鏄ャ伄鏂颁綔銉愩儍銈?銉栥儵銉炽儔銈偆銈炽兂銇儮銉庛偘銉┿儬銇ㄣ亜銇嗛伕鎶?baila銉斻儍銉嗐偅銈︺偐銉?pitti uomo 銈?銉兗銉愩兗 guy rover妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 15锛卭ff銈兗銉濄兂銇傘倞 銉嬨儱銉笺儛銉┿兂銈?new balance

trackback

bota timber and feminina hiper promo莽茫o

kj酶p salomon mantra tech legslik sminker du en naturlig lookmagasinet q kan du l忙sedamepung find de nyeste punge til kvinder online her

trackback

botinha stephen curry basquete under armour 2018 r 499

t锚nis nike infanti juveni promo莽茫o 26 ao 33 esco ha cores. carregandoprodutos em agasa hot锚nis puma infanti e su v2 s v branco preto compre agora dafiti brasifeminino nike air max 2015 sapati has todo preto brasi barato

trackback

serengeti lunettes de soleil gloria shiny rose gold drivers shaded femme

wiggle nederland new balance fresh foam 1080v7 hardloopschoenenverkoop goedkope new balance 373 olive green womens trainers all sizes available 3 4 5 6badstof meisjes schoenenpuma trinomic r698 sneakers laag grijs schoenen kopen beslist.be lage prijs

trackback

jordans kopen amsterdam

hotte aspirante silencieuse et puissante tactile hotte aspirante puissante et silencieuse largeur 90 . hotte aspirante silencieuse et puissanteacheter solaires en polycarbonate sb1005p marron santa barbara polo racquet club genreen raison de la forme c…

trackback

surprises adidas noir 茅conomique 茅charpes et foulards originals ensemble 茅charpe et homme gants

2018 acquista scontate borse unisex nike air force 1 tote bag total orange totalscarpe da ginnastica nere adidas da donna 2018 adidas scarpa economico negozioeuro 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 scarpe new balance 574 core m uomoamazon.it adidas scarpe col tac…

trackback

fila vintage bb1 borg retro seventies polo in white

popps original unisex mens womens leather desert boots tantherefore your personal bowling shoestommy hilfiger mens slim fit polo shirt cloudburst heatherreal techniques miracle complexion sponge and travel case feelunique

trackback

3d transparente magie foulard cr芒ne fant么me clown joker cache cou tube masque bandana v茅lo chapeaux bandeau

gorro de lana para ni帽as con strass y piedras bordadas. cargando zoomgorra tipo trucker modelo jimmytenis gucci mujer 2017deportivo urbano new balance gris new balance

trackback

luva nitrilica titan mucambo no

damen adult geschenke stefano elegante kleine handtasche grau taupe12er pack microfaser uomo tatto neon unterw盲sche pants herren boxershortsm.st眉tzle trachten dirndl 2tlg. apollonia blaunun 枚ffentliches hearing zu den veranstaltungen in der innenstadt

trackback

prada bt1028 tessuto nylon quilted sling bag black

xelay new mens gents black tan slip on formal shoes normal fitting. leathertommy hilfiger women blue cotton dress xjgamhjd women dresses jumpsuitscomme des garcons play comme des garcons play blue heart t shirtleo lily boys long sleeves striped cardiga…

trackback

丕胤賮丕賱 氐睾丕乇 賷賱毓亘賵賳 賰乇丞 丕賱賯丿賲 al5 year old soccer player youtube

賳馗丕乇丞 賱丕賰賵爻鬲 lacoste .. 丕爻賵丿 賮賷 匕賴亘賷 乇賵毓丞 賲賳 賱丕乇賵夭丕賱乇賷丕囟丞 賵丕賱賳卮丕胤 丕賱亘丿賳賷丌亘賱 鬲囟賷賮 賲賷夭丞 丕賱丿賮毓 賲賳 禺賱丕賱 賮丕鬲賵乇丞 丕賱賴丕鬲賮 亘丌賷 鬲賵賳夭貙 賵鬲亘丿兀 亘卮亘賰丞 o2丿乇丕爻丞 鬲乇亘胤 亘賷賳 丕賱賴賵丕鬲賮 丕賱賲丨賲賵賱丞 賵丕賱爻乇胤丕賳 賲賵賯毓 卮賵賮

trackback

womens givenchy wear online

nike lebron x elite cutting jade gr jade china blackwomens canvas chuck taylorsvans era 59 black greyair jordan 9 retro og releasing december 3rd